I read 25 books last year, and only five are worthy of inclusion
on this list. Still, these five are
pretty phenomenal, so I don’t suppose I can complain.
Without further ado, here they are. I tried to put them in order, but of course you
all know how arbitrary that is.
1.
The Privateer (Gordon Daviot, a.k.a. Josephine Tey)
If not the best
book I read in 2020, then certainly the most perfect. The
Privateer is a splendid novel, swashbuckling and witty, with fine lyrical
flourishes and enough pathos to give it depth. Henry Morgan emerges as a
dashing and fascinating figure, vain and flawed and heroic to his core.
2.
Cryptonomicon (Neal Stephenson)
A sprawling,
imperfect, brilliant book. Stephenson's at his best telling dark WWII
fairytales, full of twisted humor and surreal beauty. The present-day segments
aren't as gripping or convincing, but when you start to see the full weave of
the tapestry, you'll forgive Stephenson anything. I don't know how he manages
to be so sardonic and so humanistic and so polymathically well-informed all at
once, but he does, and it's a hell of a performance. Bravo.
3.
Sandman (the complete series, by Neil Gaiman)
Sometimes
tedious, sometimes precious, sometimes favoring words over images in a way that
seems like a disservice to the comics medium – but touched with moments of real
beauty, pathos, and brilliance, and slowly building to an ending that’s eerie,
resonant, humane, and genuinely moving. How do you evaluate a work like that?
Sandman is a work of genius – a flawed, rambling work of genius, with
tragically uneven artwork, that somehow manages to tie together most of its
multitudinous plot strands in its strange and masterful conclusion. It’s worth
the time – worth the frustration. It’s like a treasure trove of humanity’s
stories, and even if some of the jewels are pasteboard, enough are real to make
for a rich and satisfying reward.
4.
The Mirror and the Light (Hilary Mantel)
I did start to
experience a bit of Trilogy Exhaustion during this final installment, but
Mantel's vision and artistry remain breathtaking, and there's real pathos in
reaching the end of the tale.
5.
The League of Frightened Men (Rex Stout)
I read a lot of
Nero Wolfe mysteries this year, and this was the pick of the litter. Perplexing and full of menace, with an
unexpected ending and – best of all – some wonderful Wolfe/Goodwin interplay.
You can see why John Dickson Carr placed this book in his mystery top ten.